Monday, July 12, 2010

Piracy

I blame the RIAA.

Those are the geniuses who decided to start suing people who were "file sharing" music starting in 2003. They took hundreds of people to court. The vast majority of the defendants were totally and undeniably guilty of theft, but some of them were baffled, confused, and quite photogenic. Consequently, when the public thinks of online pirates, this is what they think of:














Those are all people that were all sued by the RIAA for "stealing music." And that lineup doesn't include the deceased grandmother, the family that didn't own a computer, the 12 year Brianna LaHara, and the 13 year old Brittany Chan.

These lawsuits were, in a word, "monumentally stupid."

It made the corporations (the ones spending all the money, and taking all the risks to produce this stuff) look like bullying assholes. It made Metallica (METALLICA!) look like a bunch of corporate shills. It made the layperson believe that software pirates were terrified single mothers, children, and the elderly.

But I have a secret. Here's what online pirates really look like:


Yarr.

Or, at least, that's how I picture them. They're actually (primarily) male, ranging in age between late 20s to early 40s. They're intelligent. Sophisticated. Incredibly well-organized. Usually foreign. And relentless.

To top it all off, they're also wealthy. Pirates make a lot of money doing this. A lot. Don't let the sob stories fool you. Don't think they're just providing some kind of free public service to "fight the man." The people running online piracy sites make a comfortable living, selling other peoples' creations. It's no different than a person walking into a store, stuffing a bunch of DVDs into their backpack, then walking out to the sidewalk and selling those DVDs for a dollar a piece. It's not noble. It's not "taking on money-hungry corporations." It's just straight-up stealing.

I mean, most people would never grab a DVD off of a store shelf and sneak it outside...but they'd be more than happy to watch a pirated movie online. The crime is no different...really. It's just more anonymous, and far less risky.

"But hang on a second, Tyler," you wail. "How could they possibly make money doing this? Doesn't it cost a lot of money to host these sites?"

I'm glad you asked that.

First off, any pirate site worth its salt does not host any videos. They post links that redirect you to video hosting sites (which are, a lot of the time, subscription-based...in addition to selling ad space).

But on top of that, any time you go to one of these pirate sites, you'll still get advertisements. These range from "kind of annoying" (pop-up ads and banners) to "pretty irritating" (non-skippable video ads, forced redirects) to "straight up dangerous" (adware, malware, viruses). Every site has them. And the more traffic they get, the more money they make. The more irritating the advertisement, the bigger the payout.

Consequently, these link sites encourage users to record and post movies (often without paying them a dime), while the admins sit back and collect any profit (paid to their anonymous PayPal accounts via the scammy advertising sites).

In fact, one of the major operators of these link sites is the Russian Business Network. This is a cyber-crime organization that takes the revenue earned from these pirate sites, and feeds it into child pornography, identity theft schemes, prostitution rings, the black market, and an army of malware scams. Essentially, when you go to a site run by the RBN, you're helping pay for all of these illegal activities.

And the infuriating thing for me is: these people have created nothing. They've contributed nothing. They've just set up a website, loaded it with ads and bullcrap, then pawned it off on the unwary public...because who wouldn't want to watch any movie or TV show ever filmed for free? When the RIAA filed all of their idiotic lawsuits, the pirates (and their proprietors)
look like the victims! It's incredible.

"So," you snivel, "what can I do?"

Well, in spite of all my rantings, I won't ask you to stop watching pirated movies. It's a losing battle...I know...and I don't want to seem like a square. I get the appeal. Heck, I'd be lying to you if I told you I haven't ever downloaded something illegal.

But, there's stuff you can do. Little stuff, to encourage networks to start migrating their material online. For instance, if you're presented with the option -- take the legit one. Like, instead of watching Modern Family on some shitty pirate site, just go to Hulu and tolerate the 30 second ads (you can navigate away from the screen, check your e-mail, read my blog, etc.). I think you'd feel a lot better knowing that your money is going to the people who make the stuff you watch, and not this smug little foreign dude:


Problem?

This is especially true if you're an actor, writer, director, or someone who'd like to eventually make money doing something in the arts. That guy pictured above? He's not an artist. He's not Robin Hood. He's just a thief...a bushy-eyebrow'd thief.

And if you can afford it, just rent movies or go to the theater. There are so many good, inexpensive options out there now (like Netflix, On-Demand, etc.) that you shouldn't have to cry "poverty" every time there's something good you want to watch. Again, this is especially true for the aspiring professional artists out there.

But like I say...if you watch this stuff, I ain't mad atcha'. I was a lot like you...but I've recently come to the realization that I need to be a little bit less anarchic, and a little more responsible (must have happened when I turned 30). I think we're going to get to a very exciting point where every show ever made will be available to watch at any time, anywhere (for a monthly fee). If we let these pirates dictate the rules, then none of the money will get to the people who deserve it -- these are the actors, writers, directors, producers, and studios.

That little Russian dude up there? He shouldn't be getting jack squat...because he created nothing and risked nothing...so he deserves nothing.

2 comments:

  1. Somewhere on the list of 10 greatest lies ever told is, "crime does not pay". As Gollum once said, "Oh yeth it doesh!" Many get caught, but many many more get away with it. It's my theory that any human behavior that persists for long periods of time, (think hundreds of thousands, perhaps millions of years), persists because it helps the specie to survive. If that is accurate, then the attempts by the majority, or a powerful minority at least, to deal with the resulting unwanted behavior by tracking and hunting its individual expressions will always be ineffective. Nothing reaches the root cause. Millions of people stole music, most of them upstanding citizens, some you pictured here, but most weren't prosecuted. Fear of prosecution simply tamps down that particular avenue of "criminalistic" expression, but has no affect one why millions of people stole music in the first place. Another door will open. "If it weren't for the existence of truth, lying wouldn't be worthwhile." J. Campbell in, The Liars Tale. This should not be construed as an advocacy of criminality, but as an observation that, perhaps we are going about this the wrong way. I despise criminal behavior, hell, I become almost homicidal at rude behavior. But in my more peaceful contemplations, I try to come up with different solutions to complex human behavior problems. Currently I'm thinking universal surgical implants at birth that transmit all urges, of a criminal nature, to a panel of thought police who can immediately transmit anything from a mild shock to an outright termination of biological function, depending upon the criminal severity of the contemplated activity. OK, so I didn't want you to think I just pondered pointlessly but offered no solution. On the other hand, maybe it's a tendency that shouldn't be bred out of us.

    ReplyDelete
  2. That theory you posit sounds an awful lot like something I read once. Something about a Beagle, Galápagos, and birds of some kind? It's a little fuzzy...but it sounds very familiar.

    Actually, that reminds me; I do have another book for you to read. Consider it a late father's-day gift, or a very late birthday present. I think you'll like it. I sure did.

    But yes, crime will be around so long as there is opportunity, poverty, desperation, and a reasonable expectation of "gettin' away wit' it."

    My point is, some folks may view video piracy as a minor "victim-less crime," and almost more of a convenience than anything else. Which it is...really. I mean, on the crime scale of "naughty" to "horrific," video piracy ranks pretty low.

    But at the same time, anyone who considers themselves a "responsible" person can take steps to stay on the windy side of the law (like by using Hulu and ABC.com, not Megavideo or JustinTV) Because I believe that, if you've made something, you should be the only one making money off of it...not some borscht-smelling technophile somewhere.

    I should stop picking on the Russians...but it's so much fun...

    ReplyDelete